The Rily Guide to Buying Organic
The Rily Guide to Buying Organic
This handy buyer's guide will help you discover which groceries are worth buying organic and which ones you can skip.
When shopping for groceries, it's all too easy to get caught in the crossroads of the 'organic vs. conventional' conundrum. It generally boils down to one question: is it worth the extra cost? While the organic price tag carries an implication of higher nutritional value, better flavor, fewer contaminants, and elevated ethical standards, the truth is that not all Certified Organic items are created equal. This practical guide is designed to cut to the chase, helping you decide what's more important to buy organic and what you can probably skip.
Animal Products: Prioritize Organic
Meat and milk should top your list when considering organic options. Organic meats come from happier animals raised without synthetic hormones and minimal antibiotics and are often grass-fed or pasture-raised. This results in healthier fat profiles with more omega-3s and fewer inflammatory omega-6s. Organic milk follows the same pattern, providing higher levels of beneficial fatty acids like conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) and vitamins such as A and E.
Eggs, too, are generally worth the investment. Organic eggs come from hens that are not caged, have access to the outdoors, and eat organic feed. The result is eggs with significantly higher levels of omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin D, which can improve inflammation levels and support immune health. If your budget is tight, consider prioritizing organic dairy and eggs, as they really do offer distinct nutritional advantages.
For a much deeper dive into organic and conventional animal products, see our guide Organic Eggs, Milk, Meat and Fish: Are You Getting What You Pay For.
Grains and Legumes: Often Not Necessary
When it comes to grains, legumes, and other dry goods, going organic isn't always essential. Grains like rice, quinoa, and beans typically have lower pesticide residues, even when grown conventionally. Plus, organic grains often come at a much higher price without delivering significantly different nutrient profiles. If avoiding pesticides in grains is important to you, choosing organic oats may be a good choice, as they are frequently cited for containing higher pesticide levels like glyphosate.
One area of concern with conventionally grown grains, however, is heavy metal contamination. Conventional grains may carry more cadmium due to the fertilizers used in non-organic farming, though research on this issue is still developing. If heavy metals are a concern, particularly for cereal grains, choosing organic may be a safer bet.
Fruits and Vegetables: Choose Wisely- But Choose Them!
Some fruits and vegetables are more susceptible to pesticide contamination, while others have natural defences against them. The Dirty Dozen list compiled by the Environmental Working Group (EWG) provides up-to-date guidance on the most contaminated produce. Items like strawberries, spinach, and apples have been identified to bear more pesticides, potentially making them good candidates for organic option.
On the other hand, produce with thick skins or peels, like avocados, bananas, and onions, generally have much lower pesticide residues. These can safely be purchased conventionally without sacrificing your health. Additionally, it's worth pointing out that pesticide levels in most produce- including those on the Dirty Dozen list- are well below established, conservative safety limits, so if buying organic means buying fewer fruits and veggies, it's better to focus on eating more, regardless of their organic status.
For a much deeper dive into organic and conventional produce, check out our feature Organic Produce: Is it Worth it? Or Even Any Better?
Seafood: Not Always Worth It
Organic seafood might seem like a no-brainer, but the situation is more complicated than land-based animal products. In fact, the nutritional differences between organic and conventional seafood appear minimal. Wild-caught fish often boast higher levels of essential nutrients, like omega-3s, but come with the risk of environmental contaminants like mercury. Organic fish, on the other hand, may come from more controlled environments, but there is little evidence that they are significantly more nutritious.
Ultimately, for seafood, the real debate lies between wild-caught and farm-raised fish rather than organic vs. conventional. At this point, the literature is far from conclusive on major nutritional differences between any of them. Opting for wild-caught where possible or choosing responsibly farmed fish from reputable sources to avoid unnecessary contaminants is likely a good way to navigate these waters.
Prioritize Local and Seasonal
When deciding whether to buy organic, don't overlook the importance of supporting local farms. Local, in-season produce tends to be fresher, tastier, and often has more nutrients than out-of-season fruits and vegetables that travel long distances. Even when they aren't technically certified organic, local farms generally use fewer pesticides and more sustainable practices. Plus, you'll be contributing to community economies and supporting families.
The Bottom Line
While organic foods may offer benefits like fewer pesticides and higher levels of antioxidants and nutrients, not everything on your grocery list needs to be organic. Prioritize organic when it comes to animal products like meat, milk, and eggs, as these foods show the most significant ethical and nutritional differences between organic and conventional. For fruits and vegetables, you probably don't need to worry much about it at all-and certainly don't let fear of pesticides deter you from eating them. As for grains and legumes, go organic only if heavy metals or pesticide residues are a significant concern.
In a tricky economy where just about everything seems to cost more than it should, a little bit of strategy goes a long way. At the end of the day, eating more fruits, vegetables, and whole foods- organic or not- is likely the most important step toward a healthier diet.
EWG’s dirty dozenTM and Clean FifteenTM lists are here! EWG. (2021, November 3). https://www.ewg.org/
Matthews, L. (2023, January 9). Glyphosate-Free Oatmeal: Everything You Need To Know. LeafScore. https://www.leafscore.com/grocery/glyphosate-free-oatmeal-everything-you-need-to-know/#:~:text=Yes%2C%20the%20reports%20I%20outlined,oats%20and%20organic%20oat%20products
Zielinski, D. (2024a, August 19). Organic produce: Is it worth it? or even any better? . Rily. https://www.rily.co/articles/organic-produce:-is-it-worth-it-or-even-any-better-113
Zielinski, D. (2024b, August 28). Organic eggs, milk, meat, and fish: Are you getting what you pay for? . Rily. https://www.rily.co/articles/organic-eggs-milk-meat-fish:-are-you-getting-what-you-pay-for-117
